LogTide vs ELK Stack for Log Management

The ELK Stack (Elasticsearch, Logstash, Kibana) is the most widely deployed open-source log management solution. LogTide offers a simpler alternative with fewer components, lower resource requirements, and built-in SIEM. Here’s a detailed comparison.

Architecture Comparison

ELK Stack

The ELK Stack consists of three (or more) components that must work together:

• Elasticsearch - Search and storage engine (requires cluster management)
• Logstash - Log processing pipeline (or Beats for lightweight collection)
• Kibana - Visualization and UI

Additional components often needed:

• Filebeat/Metricbeat - Data shippers
• Elastic Agent - Unified data shipper
• Elastic SIEM - Security features (paid)
• ElastAlert - Alerting (third-party)

LogTide

LogTide is a single application stack:

• Backend - API, ingestion, search, alerting, SIEM
• Frontend - Built-in web UI
• TimescaleDB - Storage (PostgreSQL-based)

That’s it. One docker compose up -d and you’re running.

Resource Comparison

One of LogTide’s biggest advantages is resource efficiency:

Component	ELK Stack	LogTide
Elasticsearch	16-32 GB RAM (heap)	-
Logstash	4-8 GB RAM	-
Kibana	2-4 GB RAM	-
Backend	-	2-4 GB RAM
TimescaleDB	-	4-8 GB RAM
Total RAM	22-44 GB	6-12 GB

LogTide uses 60-75% less memory for equivalent workloads.

Feature Comparison

Feature	ELK Stack	LogTide
Components	3+ (ES, Logstash, Kibana)	Single stack
Log ingestion	Beats, Logstash	HTTP API, SDKs, OTLP
Query language	Lucene / KQL	REST API + Full-text
Full-text search	Yes	Yes
Real-time streaming	Kibana Discover	SSE
Alerting	Watcher / ElastAlert	Built-in
Security detection	Elastic SIEM (paid)	Sigma (included)
OpenTelemetry	APM Server	Native OTLP
Cluster management	Complex (shards, replicas)	Simple (PostgreSQL)
Version compatibility	Must match all components	Single versioned release
Custom dashboards	Kibana (extensive)	SIEM dashboard

Where ELK Stack Wins

Advanced search capabilities. Elasticsearch is one of the best search engines ever built. Lucene-based queries, aggregations, and the Query DSL are incredibly powerful for complex log analysis.

Kibana dashboards. Kibana’s visualization capabilities are extensive: custom dashboards, lens, maps, canvas, and dozens of visualization types. LogTide’s dashboard is security-focused and less customizable.

Elastic ecosystem. Elastic has Beats agents for every data source imaginable: Filebeat, Metricbeat, Auditbeat, Packetbeat, Heartbeat. The agent ecosystem is mature.

Battle-tested at scale. Elasticsearch powers some of the largest search installations in the world. Its distributed architecture handles petabytes of data across hundreds of nodes.

Where LogTide Wins

Dramatically simpler. No more managing Elasticsearch clusters (shards, replicas, split-brain), Logstash pipelines (grok patterns, codec issues), and Kibana (index patterns, saved objects). LogTide is one deployment.

Lower resource requirements. ELK requires 22-44 GB RAM minimum for production. LogTide runs on 6-12 GB. That’s a 60-75% reduction in infrastructure costs.

No version headaches. ELK components must be version-matched. Upgrading Elasticsearch without matching Kibana and Logstash causes compatibility issues. LogTide is a single versioned release.

Built-in SIEM. Elastic’s security features (SIEM, endpoint security) require paid licenses. LogTide includes Sigma detection rules, MITRE ATT&CK mapping, and incident management for free.

Better compression. TimescaleDB’s columnar compression is highly efficient for time-series log data, often achieving 10-20x compression ratios.

When to Choose ELK Stack

• You need Elasticsearch’s advanced query DSL for complex analysis
• You require Kibana’s extensive dashboard and visualization capabilities
• You have existing Beats agents deployed across your infrastructure
• Your team has deep Elasticsearch expertise
• You need to handle petabyte-scale data with cluster management

When to Choose LogTide

• You want simpler operations (single stack vs 3+ components)
• Your infrastructure budget is limited (60-75% less RAM needed)
• You need SIEM capabilities without paid Elastic licenses
• You’re tired of ELK version compatibility issues
• You want built-in alerting without ElastAlert or Watcher
• You’re starting fresh and want the easiest path to production

Query Migration

Elasticsearch Query DSL to LogTide

Elasticsearch	LogTide API
{"match": {"service": "api"}}	GET /api/v1/logs?service=api
{"match": {"level": "error"}}	GET /api/v1/logs?level=error
{"query_string": {"query": "timeout"}}	GET /api/v1/logs?q=timeout
{"range": {"@timestamp": {"gte": "now-1h"}}}	GET /api/v1/logs?from=2025-01-15T11:00:00Z

KQL (Kibana Query Language) to LogTide

KQL	LogTide
service: api	?service=api
level: error OR level: critical	?level=error&level=critical
"connection timeout"	?q=connection%20timeout
service: api AND level: error	?service=api&level=error

Concept Mapping

ELK	LogTide	Notes
Index	Project	One index pattern = One project
Document	Log entry	1:1 mapping
Field	metadata key	Custom fields stored in metadata JSON
@timestamp	time	ISO 8601 format
Filebeat	Fluent Bit / SDK	Use Fluent Bit for file tailing
Logstash	Fluent Bit / SDK	Use Fluent Bit filters or preprocess in app
Kibana	LogTide UI	Built-in web interface
Watcher	Alert Rules	Simpler configuration
Elastic SIEM	Sigma Rules + SIEM Dashboard	Included at no extra cost

Migration Path

Our migration guide covers replacing Beats/Logstash with Fluent Bit, translating Elasticsearch queries, migrating Watcher alerts, and handling Logstash pipeline transformations.

View the full ELK migration guide

---

Ready to simplify your log stack?

• Deploy LogTide - Free, open-source
• Migration Guide - Step-by-step instructions
• Join GitHub Discussions - Get help from the community